Xeon Silver 4516Y vs i5-8600K
Primary details
Comparing Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y processor market type (desktop or notebook), architecture, sales start time and price.
| Place in the ranking | 1049 | not rated |
| Place by popularity | not in top-100 | not in top-100 |
| Cost-effectiveness evaluation | 3.94 | no data |
| Market segment | Desktop processor | Server |
| Series | Intel Core i5 | no data |
| Power efficiency | 6.40 | no data |
| Architecture codename | Coffee Lake-S (2017−2018) | no data |
| Release date | 24 September 2017 (7 years ago) | 1 October 2023 (1 year ago) |
| Launch price (MSRP) | $257 | no data |
Cost-effectiveness evaluation
Performance per price, higher is better.
Detailed specifications
Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y basic parameters such as number of cores, number of threads, base frequency and turbo boost clock, lithography, cache size and multiplier lock state. These parameters indirectly say of CPU speed, though for more precise assessment you have to consider their test results.
| Physical cores | 6 (Hexa-Core) | 24 (Tetracosa-Core) |
| Threads | 6 | 48 |
| Base clock speed | 3.6 GHz | 2.2 GHz |
| Boost clock speed | 4.3 GHz | 3.7 GHz |
| Bus type | DMI 3.0 | no data |
| Bus rate | 4 × 8 GT/s | no data |
| Multiplier | 36 | no data |
| L1 cache | 384 KB | no data |
| L2 cache | 1.5 MB | no data |
| L3 cache | 9 MB (shared) | 45 MB |
| Chip lithography | 14 nm | Intel 7 nm |
| Die size | 149 mm2 | no data |
| Maximum core temperature | 100 °C | 81 °C |
| Maximum case temperature (TCase) | 72 °C | no data |
| 64 bit support | + | - |
| Windows 11 compatibility | + | no data |
| Unlocked multiplier | + | - |
Compatibility
Information on Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y compatibility with other computer components: motherboard (look for socket type), power supply unit (look for power consumption) etc. Useful when planning a future computer configuration or upgrading an existing one. Note that power consumption of some processors can well exceed their nominal TDP, even without overclocking. Some can even double their declared thermals given that the motherboard allows to tune the CPU power parameters.
| Number of CPUs in a configuration | 1 (Uniprocessor) | no data |
| Socket | FCLGA1151 | FCLGA4677 |
| Power consumption (TDP) | 95 Watt | 185 Watt |
Technologies and extensions
Technological solutions and additional instructions supported by Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y. You'll probably need this information if you require some particular technology.
| Instruction set extensions | Intel® SSE4.1, Intel® SSE4.2, Intel® AVX2 | Intel® AMX, Intel® SSE4.2, Intel® AVX, Intel® AVX2, Intel® AVX-512 |
| AES-NI | + | + |
| AVX | + | - |
| vPro | + | no data |
| Enhanced SpeedStep (EIST) | + | no data |
| Speed Shift | no data | + |
| Turbo Boost Technology | 2.0 | 2.0 |
| Hyper-Threading Technology | + | + |
| TSX | + | + |
| Idle States | + | no data |
| Thermal Monitoring | + | - |
| SIPP | + | - |
| Deep Learning Boost | - | + |
Security technologies
Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y technologies aimed at improving security, for example, by protecting against hacks.
| TXT | + | + |
| EDB | + | + |
| Secure Key | + | no data |
| MPX | + | - |
| Identity Protection | + | - |
| SGX | Yes with Intel® ME | Yes with Intel® SPS |
| OS Guard | + | + |
Virtualization technologies
Virtual machine speed-up technologies supported by Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y are enumerated here.
| AMD-V | + | - |
| VT-d | + | + |
| VT-x | + | + |
| EPT | + | + |
Memory specs
Types, maximum amount and channel quantity of RAM supported by Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y. Depending on the motherboard, higher memory frequencies may be supported.
| Supported memory types | DDR3, DDR4 | DDR5-4400 |
| Maximum memory size | 128 GB | 4 TB |
| Max memory channels | 2 | 8 |
| Maximum memory bandwidth | 42.671 GB/s | no data |
| ECC memory support | - | + |
Graphics specifications
General parameters of integrated GPUs, if any.
| Integrated graphics card | Intel UHD Graphics 630 | no data |
| Max video memory | 64 GB | no data |
| Quick Sync Video | + | - |
| Clear Video | + | no data |
| Clear Video HD | + | no data |
| Graphics max frequency | 1.15 GHz | no data |
| InTru 3D | + | no data |
Graphics interfaces
Available interfaces and connections of Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y integrated GPUs.
| Number of displays supported | 3 | no data |
Graphics image quality
Maximum display resolutions supported by Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y integrated GPUs, including resolutions over different interfaces.
| 4K resolution support | + | no data |
| Max resolution over HDMI 1.4 | 4096x2304@24Hz | no data |
| Max resolution over eDP | 4096x2304@60Hz | no data |
| Max resolution over DisplayPort | 4096x2304@60Hz | no data |
Graphics API support
APIs supported by Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y integrated GPUs, sometimes API versions are included.
| DirectX | 12 | no data |
| OpenGL | 4.5 | no data |
Peripherals
Specifications and connection of peripherals supported by Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y.
| PCIe version | 3.0 | 5.0 |
| PCI Express lanes | 16 | 80 |
Pros & cons summary
| Recency | 24 September 2017 | 1 October 2023 |
| Physical cores | 6 | 24 |
| Threads | 6 | 48 |
| Power consumption (TDP) | 95 Watt | 185 Watt |
i5-8600K has 94.7% lower power consumption.
Xeon Silver 4516Y, on the other hand, has an age advantage of 6 years, and 300% more physical cores and 700% more threads.
We couldn't decide between Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y. We've got no test results to judge.
Note that Core i5-8600K is a desktop processor while Xeon Silver 4516Y is a server/workstation one.
Should you still have questions on choice between Core i5-8600K and Xeon Silver 4516Y, ask them in Comments section, and we shall answer.
Similar processor comparisons
We picked several similar comparisons of processors in the same market segment and performance relatively close to those reviewed on this page.
